If you own a business in Anchorage or elsewhere in Alaska and expect to sell it someday, the phrase "quality of earnings" will probably come up. Buyers, lenders, and private equity groups often ask for a quality of earnings review before they close a deal. Sellers increasingly order one before they go to market.
This article explains what a quality of earnings (QoE) review is, how it differs from an audit or a valuation, what it typically examines, and how owners can prepare.
What is a quality of earnings review?
A quality of earnings review is a financial due diligence analysis. It asks whether a company's reported earnings are sustainable, repeatable, and supported by evidence.
Reported net income tells you what happened in the books. A QoE review asks what that income says about the future. For example, would the earnings continue under a new owner? Were they inflated or depressed by one-time events? Are they backed by cash?
The usual output is an "adjusted EBITDA" figure, meaning earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization after normalizing adjustments. The review also includes a written explanation of each adjustment and the risks the reviewer identified.
How is it different from an audit or a valuation?
These three services are related but answer different questions:
- An audit gives an opinion on whether financial statements are fairly presented under an accounting framework. It looks backward and follows formal standards.
- A quality of earnings review focuses on whether the earnings are reliable as a basis for pricing a transaction. It is more targeted and often more forward-looking than an audit.
- A business valuation estimates what a business or ownership interest is worth under a defined standard of value. Normalized earnings from a QoE often feed into a valuation, but a valuation also considers risk, growth, market data, and the specific interest being valued.
Many transactions use more than one of these. Knowing which question you need answered helps you hire the right help.
What does a QoE review typically examine?
The scope varies with the deal, but most reviews look at several common areas.
1. Normalizing adjustments. These remove items that won't continue under new ownership. Examples include owner compensation above or below market rates, personal expenses paid by the company, related-party rent that doesn't match market rates, and one-time legal or repair costs. Each adjustment should be documented. Buyers commonly push back on add-backs that can't be supported.
2. Revenue quality. Reviewers look at how revenue is recognized, whether there are timing issues near period-end, how concentrated revenue is among a few customers, and whether contracts support the reported figures. In Alaska, many businesses depend on seasonal activity, government or resource-sector contracts, or a small number of large customers. Concentration and seasonality deserve a clear explanation.
3. Expense trends and margins. Are gross margins steady or drifting? Have costs been deferred in ways that flatter recent results, such as postponed maintenance or staffing gaps?
4. Working capital. Buyers usually expect a "normal" level of working capital to come with the business. A QoE review analyzes historical receivables, inventory, and payables to help set that target. Working capital disputes are a common source of post-closing friction.
5. Proof of cash. Reviewers often reconcile reported revenue and expenses to bank activity. Gaps between the books and the bank are among the issues buyers take most seriously.
6. Tie-out to tax returns. Differences between the financial statements and the tax returns aren't automatically a problem, but they need to be explainable.
7. Debt and debt-like items. Deferred revenue, unpaid bonuses, customer deposits, deferred payroll, and pending claims can all affect what a buyer is willing to pay.
Why sellers benefit from going first
A buyer's QoE review is designed to protect the buyer. If it finds problems late in the process, the seller may face a price reduction, extra escrow or holdback demands, tougher contract terms, or a deal that stalls.
A sell-side QoE review, done before marketing the business, lets the owner:
- Identify and fix issues on their own timeline
- Prepare documentation for add-backs in advance
- Present a cleaner, more credible financial story to buyers
- Negotiate from facts rather than react to findings
It doesn't eliminate buyer diligence, and it doesn't guarantee a particular price. But it can reduce surprises, and surprises late in a deal are rarely in the seller's favor.
Common issues that surface in smaller-company deals
From our perspective as valuation and forensic accountants, issues that often come up in owner-managed businesses include:
- Personal and business expenses mixed in the same accounts
- Cash-basis books that don't reflect accruals at year-end
- Unrecorded or informal agreements with family members or related entities
- Large, unexplained journal entries near year-end
- Inventory counts that haven't been reconciled to the books
- Heavy reliance on the owner for customer relationships or key operations
None of these automatically ruins a sale. Each one is easier to address with a year or two of lead time than in the middle of a negotiation.
How to prepare: a practical starting list
If a sale may happen in the next few years, consider:
- Separating personal and business spending going forward, and documenting past personal items.
- Reconciling bank and credit card accounts monthly and keeping the support.
- Reviewing revenue recognition with your CPA, especially for multi-period contracts or deposits.
- Documenting related-party arrangements in writing, at terms you can explain.
- Reducing owner dependence, so key relationships and processes don't rest on one person.
- Getting an independent view of your normalized earnings and value before you talk to buyers.
How TruVim CPA can help
TruVim CPA is an Anchorage-based firm focused on business valuation, forensic accounting, litigation support, and M&A advisory, along with tax services. We help Alaska business owners understand their numbers the way a buyer will, so they can make informed decisions about timing, preparation, and price.
To start a conversation, use our contact form, call (907) 929-0309, or email info@truvim.com. Our office is at 2907 Iris Drive, Anchorage.
Frequently asked questions
Is a quality of earnings review the same as an audit?
No. An audit gives a formal opinion on financial statements. A QoE review focuses on whether earnings are sustainable and supported as a basis for a transaction. Some deals use both.
Who pays for a quality of earnings review?
It depends on who orders it. Buyers usually pay for their own diligence. Sellers who want a sell-side review usually pay for that one.
How long does a QoE review take?
Timing depends on the company's size, the quality of its records, and the scope. Well-organized books and quick access to documents typically shorten the process.
Does a sell-side QoE guarantee a higher sale price?
No. It can help a seller present credible numbers and reduce late-stage surprises, but price depends on the market, the buyer, and the terms negotiated.
When should I start preparing to sell?
Many advisors suggest starting two to three years before an expected sale, which leaves time to address issues and build a consistent track record.
This article is for general information only and is not tax, legal, or investment advice. Consult a qualified professional about your specific situation.